Thursday 11 December 2014

TIADA Dokumen NSA, tiada BUKTI ? pendakwa JERMAN Mengatakan tidak DAPAT Membuktikan Amerika Syarikat MENOREH telefon Merkel



Srikandi -Ketua pendakwa Jerman berkata masih tiada bukti kukuh yg menghu-bungkan NSA kepada menoreh telefon Canselor Angela Merkel, terutama kerana siasatan gagal mendapatkan memegang dokumen NSA asal yang memberi kuasa yang mengintip.

BACA lebih lanjut: Jerman untuk menyiasat dakwaan NSA pengintipan telefon Canselor Merkel READ MORE: Germany to probe alleged NSA snooping of Chancellor Merkel's phone

Pendakwa Harald Range mendedahkan bahawa ianya telah terbukti sukar untuk mendapatkan bukti yang akan berdiri di mahkamah sejak siasatan bermula pada bulan Jun, berikutan pendedahan bekas kontraktor Agensi Keselamatan Negara Edward Snowden mengenai menoreh komunikasi para pemimpin DUNIA. Outlet Jerman Der Spiegel memecahkan cerita mengenai mengintip telefon Angela Merkel khususnya.

"Sehingga hari ini, tidak ada bukti yang membawa kepada caj data sambungan yg telah direkodkan atau panggilan telefon dengan Canselor telah mendengar," kata Pertengahan di sebuah televisyen akhir tahun sidang akhbar pada Khamis.

BACA lebih lanjut: ahli parlimen Jerman bertanya Snowden memberikan keterangan berhubung pengawasan besar-besaran walaupun tekanan k'jaan READ MORE: German lawmakers to ask Snowden testify over mass surveillance despite govt pressure

Untuk hal ini, beliau berkata, pihak berkuasa Jerman tidak dapat mendapatkan memegang dokumen NSA yang sahih yang membenarkan ‘wiretapping’ telefon Merkel.

"Dokumen dibentangkan di khalayak ramai sebagai bukti yang menoreh yg sebenar bagi telefon mudah alih tidak adalah suatu perintah pengawasan sahih oleh NSA. Ia tidak datang dari pangkalan data NSA itu, "kata pendakwa.

Pertengahan berkata editor di Spiegel disediakan laporan akhbar tersebut atas dasar dokumen NSA dia diperiksa secara visual/diperiksa.

No NSA doc, no evidence? German prosecutor says can’t prove US tapped Merkel’s phone . . .

Germany’s chief prosecutor said there is still no hard evidence linking the NSA to the tapping of Chancellor Angela Merkel’s phone, especially because the investigation failed to get a hold of the original NSA document authorizing the spying.


Prosecutor Harald Range revealed that it has proven difficult to obtain evidence that would stand up in court since the investigation began in June, following former National Security Agency contractor Edward Snowden’s revelations of the tapping of world leaders’ communications. German outlet Der Spiegel broke the story on the spying of Angela Merkel’s phone in particular.

“As of today, there is no evidence leading to charges that connection data were recorded or a phone call by the chancellor was listened to,” Range said at a televised year-end news conference on Thursday.


Crucially, he said, German authorities were not able to get a hold of the authentic NSA document which authorized the wiretapping of Merkel’s phone.

“The document presented in public as proof of an actual tapping of the mobile phone is not an authentic surveillance order by the NSA. It does not come from the NSA database,” the prosecutor said.

Range said that an editor at Spiegel prepared the paper's report on the basis of the NSA documents he visually inspected/examined.

Ketua Negeri Pendakwa Harald Range (Chief State Prosecutor Harald Range (Reuters/Alex Domanski)

BACA lebih lanjut: Jerman untuk menggugurkan penyiasatan Amerika Syarikat mengintip Merkel – laporan READ MORE: Germany to drop investigation into US spying on Merkel - report

Sementara itu, NSA kekal tenang sepanjang siasatan dan Snowden masih belum memberi maklum balas kepada jemputan untuk memberikan pernyataan bertulis dengan pengetahuannya tentang ‘wiretapping’ itu.

Juga, permintaan Range untuk agensi perisikan Jerman "tidak mengambil kami lagi," katanya.

Walaupun banyak kemajuan, Range berkata siasatan itu berterusan. Terdapat juga berharap bahawa suatu siasatan parlimen selari dalam kejadian itu akan meng-hasilkan sesuatu yang baru.

BACA lebih lanjut: Merkel dilaporkan mendapat telefon NSA-bukti dengan cip bernilai euro 2.5k READ MORE: Merkel reportedly gets NSA-proof phone with chip costing 2.5k euros

Skandal itu pada mulanya berlaku apabila wartawan yang bekerja dgn dokumen bocor Snowden yang dihubungi kerajaan Jerman untuk mendapatkan penjelasan. Ahli politik Jerman kemudiannya mencadangkan melibatkan Snowden sebagai saksi dalam kes wiretapping itu.

Menurut laporan Der Spiegel ini, telefon mudah alih Canselor Jerman yang telah di senarai sasaran NSA sejak tahun 2002 dan telah kod-bernama 'GE Canselor Merkel.' Mengintip itu masih berkuat kuasa walaupun beberapa minggu sebelum lawatan Presiden Amerika Syarikat Barack Obama ke Berlin pada bulan Jun 2013.

Berikutan ayat-ayat, orang ramai Jerman menjadi berang dan hubungan antara kedua-dua negara-negara dingin.

BACA lebih lanjut: 'Seperti Stasi': Merkel disamakan NSA untuk terkenal perkhidmatan keselamatan Jerman READ MORE: ‘Like the Stasi’: Merkel likened NSA to infamous German security service


Meanwhile, the NSA remained quiet throughout the investigation and Snowden is yet to respond to an invitation to provide a written statement on his knowledge of the wiretapping.

Also, Range’s requests to Germany’s spy agency "haven't taken us further," he said.

Despite little progress, Range said that the investigation continues. There is also hope that a parallel parliamentary inquiry into the incident will yield something new.


The scandal initially broke when journalists working with Snowden’s leaked documents contacted the German government for clarification. German politicians subsequently suggested involving Snowden as a witness in the wiretapping case.

According to Der Spiegel’s reports, the German chancellor’s mobile phone has been on an NSA target list since 2002 and was code-named 'GE Chancellor Merkel.' The spying was still in force even a few weeks before US President Barack Obama’s visit to Berlin in June 2013.

Following the revelations, the German public was outraged and relations between the two countries cooled.



Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...